There are a number of
considerations to address in a networked mobile
repeater as well as what the repeater owner
wishes to accomplish after deploying the
repeater. No matter how simple or complex
the needs, all installations will need a minimum
of the following:
From this simple list,
one can add additional components to accomplish much more:
-
0, 1 or 2 antennas (no
antennas are actually "needed")
-
Duplexer (flat pack
preferred, simple and cheap)
-
Battery back-up
(other than primary start battery for vehicle)
-
Flexible 12 VDC
power-pole distribution/ management with battery
re-charging
-
Laptop use requiring
DC power and Internet service
What you choose to use
will likely be driven by what your "needs" are in a
networked mobile repeater environment. If all you need
is to have a networked repeater while you are driving or
stopped for a restaurant or other short periods out of the
car with needs to provide HT access, then the short list
above can work adequately.
At the other end of the
scale are deployments that must run 7/24, higher RF levels
for larger coverage areas, Internet access to multiple
devices or to to service public service events, civil
emergencies, search and rescue, ham conventions where you
must get into the arena, shopping mall excursions or
trailhead hiking. Disclaimer:
We don't know it all, so don't trust us with your time and
money and if you know more, how to do it better,
please let us know so that we can incorporate it
here so that it can benefit those who may come after us.
Once you settle on "need"
and have the components, it would be helpful for you to know how
best to get it on-the-air quickly and more effectively...so
that it can work on the first trip out. That is the
real purpose of this page. Using what we have done by
trial and error on the Verizon data network and
understanding what can and cannot be
controlled should help you make it a working project that can
be counted on to perform dependably for a wireless
connection in motion. Much of this information can be
applied to any service provider as well as the hardware
needed to get data into a TRBO repeater.
Obviously the wild card
in this project is the wireless data service. We
assume you already know how to deploy a garage repeater onto
an IPSC network and only the Internet in motion is the key
variable. It is the linchpin of course so this page
will focus on the data side primarily. TRBO only uses
an average of 18 MB per day for an average 5 repeater
network connected to DCI and MARC feeds with typical
TX times into
the mobile repeater. Even on the $15 for 7 day pre-paid tier,
you will should never use your miserly 250 MB allotment.
We began with a
cradlepoint router and Verizon USB LTE dongle for Hamvention 2012. We are now supporting
the MiFi solution actively...because:
-
It works; some
models support external cellular antennas, a very
helpful option
-
It is very portable;
double duty for hotspots in your pocket, stationary and
TRBO
-
It is useful for both
repeater and other data; laptops, tablets and
smartphones
-
Relatively
inexpensive (~$100-$200 new, pre-paid, pay as you go and $20
monthly as a 2nd device)
DCI has 2 repeater owners
who have MiFi and have used them for TRBO repeaters on the
road in the last few months for several thousand miles of
experience. Other solutions are out there certainly.
Our bigger problems have been data, UDP and changing public
IP's on the mobile repeaters, but much of this information
should still be useful to those who care to use other
services and cellular data devices.
So having set the stage
for this project, let's move on to cellular data and getting
it into your repeater.
Verizon MiFi 5510L (no
external antenna port) and MiFi MHS2911 (with
external antenna port)
The MiFi has the best
USA coverage and is inexpensive to use for TRBO.
Some models may be more useful as they may
have a cellular antenna port which will enhance
coverage over the internal antennas especially if
you will be traveling through rural areas of the
country. Other benefits with a MiFi are that
they are handy, portable, battery powered, very
small and can be used for other data purposes to
soften the overall cost of ownership if only used
for a mobile TRBO repeater.
Service
can be as cheap as $15 (250 MB @ $2.15 a day for 7 days) or
$60 (60 GB @ $2 a
day for 30 days) for pre-paid or as little as $20 a
month for an additional MiFi device on an existing/shared
data plan. See:
Verizon Data Plans
MiFi's support ONLY WiFi
connections, so one needs to use a bridging device
to change the WiFi to Ethernet. We use the
Ubiquiti
Nanostation Loco M2's as they are high
quality, low cost devices, only
$53 from Amazon and we had them in stock for use
normal data point to point solutions for other TRBO
projects. Any other client bridge can be used
also.
Once the M2 is configured, it needs no further
attention as it will auto connect to the MiFi device
upon power up. See:
Loco M2
set-up
Be sure you repeater is
programmed correctly for M2 client bridge. You may use DHCP or Static on
your repeater. We suggest DHCP (and these
pages support it) so that the
repeater can move from the stationary location to the car and not need to necessarily open
CPS to make any changes. Static IP for the
repeater is fine also. Be sure your client
bridge is set up to match the repeater.
Once on the network, does it
work? We use the c-Bridge Net Watch page for
it's extensive diagnostics. One can use RDAC
also but that requires a PC and most tablets can use
Net watch via the web browser to check repeater
operation on the network and UDP ports.
However you manage it, it is handy to be able to
monitor your network while deployed. |
Other items for Mobile
Repeater Installs
-
IPSC Network Master;
physical, c-bridge or SmartPTT and why or why not
(important)
-
Antennas, Duplexer
and Frequency separation
-
current draw of all
devices
-
typical data use;
very little for TRBO (18mb a day for 5 repeater network;
1+4 with MARC/DCI)
-
Number of peer
devices on the IPSC network is a consideration and why
-
Determining if you
are on or off the TRBO network (on or off
Verizon's network to a lesser degree)
-
LTE, 3G, 2G and which
is best to use and why
IPSC Network Master:
This is important. You
should (must) be on an IPSC network that is running a
physical master repeater such as the common 8300's or
8400's. If your network is using a c-Bridge or
SmartPTT as a master, then your results are very likely to
be disappointing. It appears that the 3rd party
solutions are not as robust or compatible to a mobile
deployment. We feel this is due to both varying IP's
and UDP ports that are constantly changing as the repeater
hand-off to different cell sites. The physical
MotoTRBO repeaters appears to handle these variations far
better and this keeps your repeater on the network much more
consistently than a 3rd party device. If you repeater
is not in motion, then we have found that there is little to
no consideration to the type of device used (data service).
Antennas, Duplexer and
Frequency separation: Consider your use of zero, one or
two antennas. If you plan to use your repeater only
while driving, no duplexer or antennas are needed and you
can use your mobile radio or HT. If
you want slightly better coverage while outside of your car, put a spike on the
receiver. If you want fair coverage but no duplexer,
use a mag mount spike on the TX and stick it to the repeater
chassis and put the receiver on the roof mount. If you
are not using a duplexer at all, consider using a 15 meg
split for better coverage as well as the lowest TX power
setting possible. We use 1 watt out into the spike and
a rooftop gainer on the receiver and with a 2 watt HT, have
better than .5 mile coverage through a pine forest with -95
dBm RSSI on the HT and -59 dBm RSSI on the repeater when
deployed on a 15 meg split. If you need high power and
wide area coverage then you must use a duplexer and the 6
cavity flat packs are perfect for this purpose.
Power up with 12VDC:
All devices work fine on 12 volts. Current draw is
about 2 amps for the repeater idling and 2.5 while TX'ing at
1 watt. Add .5 amps for the MiFi and M2 client Bridge
and you are well under 4 amps worst case. Battery
backup is worth considering if you have any plans to let the
the repeater run for long periods of activity or overnight.
All power can be tied to one point for ignition on operation
or use an always on point. The better approach is to
run on back-up battery (ASM's or gell cells) and add in
re-charge when engine is running. You will need to get
12V into the battery revert port on the repeater, AC
optional if you plan to be stationary for long periods but
the revert will only re-charge at 500-600 mA. You
might add a small Astron PS to the 110 option to quickly
bring the batteries back to full charge.
Typical data use:
It may surprise you how little data is needed for TRBO
communications. We have found that with a 5 repeater
IPSC network connected into both DCI and DMR-MARC uses about
18 MB a day with typical activity day in and day out.
If you must keep to a minimum amount of daily data
consumption you can either limit your TX time into your
mobile repeater or have fewer peers on the IPSC network you
are using. The more peers and active timeslots on the network (only while
you are transmitting into your mobile repeater) the more data required. Even on
the stingy 250 MB Verizon pre-paid plan, this should never
be an issue. You actually can go mobile repeater for a
week to Dayton and back for $15.
Determining if you
are on or off the TRBO network: Unless you
hear networked activity from your repeater in motion, you
will not know with any certainty, that you are actually,
connected to the IPSC network. The c-Bridge Net watch
easily provides you that clue. Many c-Bridge owners
have graciously enabled guest accounts for use by the TRBO
community. There are also last heard lists made
public, and now this
live last heard from
DARC. But the best way to determine complete and
working connectivity is to have a conversation.
Well that is not going to work for monitoring so an active
c-Bridge Net watch is really what you need. Those
require
higher level accounts with much proprietary information, so
that is not likely to be available, but this
DCI Last Heard can help, though use must manually
refresh your browser. So what is the
solution? If EchoLink of TRBOVUi is available,
wonderful. Again not likely. So, for now until
there is really nothing readily available. Maybe a
Parrot talkgroup will some day grace our networks. Or
worse, a touch tone enabled talk-back device much like the
EchoLink test server.
LTE, 3G, 2G: Which
is best to use and why? This is a bit sketchy at
this point and input would be appreciated. When we
used a Cradlepoint with a Verizon USB dongle for 5000 miles
to Hamvention 2012 and back, we found that we had fewer
issues with tower hand-offs if we ran at 2G connections.
Our recent experiences with MiFi tend to tell us LTE is OK
to use. At this point, if you are not needing LTE speeds for a laptop or tablet, it may be best if you
lock down to EVDO only. More on this if/when we gather
more input.
Other odds and ends, tips
or hints...tis the catch-all bin
-
Place your MiFi so
you can watch it's display; know that you have
service, it's strength and data consumption if you are
on a very limited plan, especially if you are using a
tablet or PC to monitor the network and/or Email etc.
-
Buffering delays;
if you can hear audio from land based TRBO network, the
delay experienced through Verizon is a function of
signal strength; 2 seconds is good, 5-20 seconds is very
poor.
-
Signal Strength;
RSSI's less than about -95 dBm are subject to
delays, audio drop-outs, poor comm quality.
-
EVDO suggested;
1x is not useable, LTE is not yet in wide release,
locking to "EVDO only" is likely to be the best overall
setting to limit the number of service changes as you
move between 3G, 4G and LTE areas. If you are in a
major urban area, leave the MiFi set to automatic.
-
Signal drops and
tower hand-offs; typically 30-45 seconds is needed
before your repeater comes back on the IPSC network if
Verizon service is dropped or has a poor tower hand-off.
-
Permanent
vehicular WiFi; MiFi may not be the best device for
long term use in a vehicle and the Cradlepoint may be
the better solution. Unknown if the the current
Cradlepoint/Verizon combination works as well as the
MiFi for this specific TRBO use. Traveling to
Hamvention 2012 we found they did not. More input
is needed.
-
Repeater Fan
Control; I have a DPDT center off mini-toggle
mounted above the PS fan; down is PS fan only, up is PS
and TX fans enabled for normal operation. The PS
fan runs when powered by 12VDC and is noisy inside the
vehile as well as when the ambient air temp is high, the
TX fan ramps up like a jet even though the TX is ambient
cool. Now, while running 1-5 watts on 12VDC, I
have the choice between fans...and still normal duty
when returned to stationary use on 110VAC and at higher
TX power.
We would appreciate feedback
on your mobile repeater experiences and especially
your experience with MiFi and Cradlepoint while in
motion. Please Email:
dci@trbo.org |
|